Our Menu
Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish, or eggs may increase your risk of food borne illness, especially if you have certain medical conditions | (GF) - Gluten Free
Appetizers
Sampler
$18.00
Mozzarella sticks, Onion Rings, Fried Clams, & Fried Shrimp.
Jumbo Gulf Shrimp Cocktail
$13.00
Served with cocktail sauce.
Potato Skins
$10.00
Topped with monterey jack cheese, bacon, green onions, & sour cream.
Baltimore Crabcake
$15.00
Jumbo lump crab meat with J.O. spice.
Cajun Shrimp Tacos
$16.00
3 tacos topped with fried Cajun shrimp, Monterey jack cheese, slaw & cilantro lime sauce
Doo-Wa-Ditties
$11.00
Chicken bites tossed in your choice of sauce: homemade BBQ, honey mustard, parmesan garlic
Smoked Gouda Bites
$10.00
Smoked Gouda mac and cheese breaded and fried
Soup
New England Clam Chowder
$10.00/Cup
$11.00/Bowl
$12.00/XL Bowl
Lobster Bisque
$13.00/Cup
$14.00/Bowl
$15.00/XL Bowl
Turf
Comes with two sides of your choice
Center Cut Filet
$28.00/4oz
$42.00/6oz
$56.00/8oz
USDA choice hand-cut tenderloin
Ribeye
$55.00/14oz
$60.00/16oz
USDA Choice
NY Strip Steak
$47.00/12oz
USDA choice
Chicken Breast
$16.00/8oz
Blackened or fried
Can be served as a sandwich
Can be served as a sandwich
St. Louis BBQ Ribs
$23.00
1/2 rack St. Louis style ribs, smoked, grilled and topped with homemade BBQ
Bistro Medallions
$28.00
Two 4oz medallions
Steak Burger
$17.00
with cheese, lettuce, tomato, and onion
Garlic Parmesan Sauce
$0.50
Top any items with this sauce to add a little extra flavor
Cajun Sauce
$0.50
Top any items with this sauce to add a little extra flavor
Sides
Twice baked potato
$0.50/Cheese
$0.50/Bacon
Creamy whipped potatoes with sour cream, butter, salt and pepper served in a crock. Top with cheese and/or bacon for $.50 each
Baked Potato
Rice Pilaf
French Fries
Veggie of the day
Tossed Salad
Coleslaw
Potato Salad
Applesauce
Pasta
Can be topped with any available sauce of your choice
Onion Rings
$2.00
upgrade your side
Cup of soup
$5.00
Upgrade your side
Salads
Dressing options: Buttermilk Ranch | Red French | Raspberry Vinaigrette | Sweet and Sour | House Made Italian | Thousand Island | Fat-Free Italian | Blue Cheese +$1.00 • Top any salad with Feta cheese $0.75, bacon for $1 or Monterey jack cheese for $0.50 | Add Chicken, Salmon, or Steak to any salad for $8
The Wedge
$14.00
Iceberg lettuce, fresh tomato, bacon and blue cheese dressing.
Tossed Green Salad
$5.00
House greens, cucumber, tomato, onion, red cabbage, carrots, & black olive
Greek Salad
$15.00
House greens, onions, feta cheese, bacon bits, Greek olives, hard boiled eggs, pepperoncini, tomatoes, cucumbers, & homemade Italian dressing.
Maple Pecan Salmon
$17.00
Maple Glazed salmon, house greens, onions, blue cheese crumbles, apples, pecans, balsamic vinaigrette
Surf
Served with two sides of your choice
Icelandic Scrod
$23.00/8oz
Caught in Iceland and shipped in Fresh. Can be prepared broiled, topped with butter crumbs, fried, or broiled with cheese and mushroom sauce
Atlantic Salmon
$21.00/8oz
Fresh and hand-fileted in our fish market. Can be blackened or broiled
Sea Scallops
$35.00/8oz
Fresh quarter-sized scallops. Can be prepared blackened, broiled or fried
Lake Erie Perch
$18.00/4oz
$30.00/8oz
Lightly hand breaded and fried. Can be served as a sandwich
Baltimore Crab Cakes
$35.00
Two 3oz cakes made with premium jumbo lump crab meat
Maine Lobster Tail
$23.00/4oz
$43.00/7oz
$55.00/9oz
$77.00/13
$97.00/16
Premium cold water Maine lobster tail.
Snow Crab Legs
$48.00
One pound and a quarter of sweet Alaskan Snow Crab
King Crab Legs
$95.00
1# of meaty and juicy Alaskan King Crab legs
Jumbo Shrimp
$27.00
Wild caught Gulf shrimip. Chemical Free. Can be prepared grilled, fried, scampi
Icelandic Haddock
$21.00
Caught in Iceland and shipped in Fresh. Can be prepared broiled, with buttered crumbs, fried or beer battered and fried
Hil-Mak Favorites
Served with 2 sides of your choice
Shrimp Tsunami
$32.00
A shrimp platter: fried, grilled, scampi, and stuffed topped with green onions
Shrimpster
$45.00
Our trio combo platter includes a skewer of grilled shrimp, 3oz broiled scallops, and a 5oz lobster tail
Crabster
$52.00
Our trio combo platter includes a Baltimore crab cake, 3oz broiled scallops, and a 5oz lobster tail
Haddock and Scallops in Lobster Bisque
$35.00
Haddock topped with butter crumbs and seasoned scallops in a boat of lobster bisque
BBQ Chicken and Ribs
$30.00
1/2 rack of BBQ St. Louis Style Ribs, BBQ grilled chicken breast
Add ons
Add on any items to create your own combination!
Icelandic Scrod
$12.00/4oz
Can be prepared broiled, topped with butter crumbs, fried, or broiled with cheese and mushroom sauce
Atlantic Salmon
$9.00/4oz
Can be blackened or broiled
Sea Scallops
$10.00/3oz
Can be prepared blackened, broiled or fried
Baltimore Crab Cake
$16.00/3oz
One 3oz crab cake made with premium jumbo lump crab meat
Maine Lobster Tail
$25.00/4oz
$41.00/7oz
$53.00/9oz
$75.00/13oz
$95.00/16oz
Snow Crab Legs
$12.00
One cluster of sweet Alaskan snow crab.
King Crab
$45.00
1/2#
Large Shrimp
$9.00
Grilled, fried, or scampi
Lake Erie Perch
$13.00/4oz
Lightly hand breaded and deep fried
Icelandic Haddock
$9.00/4oz
Can be prepared broiled, with buttered crumbs, fried or beer battered and fried
Sauces
Garlic Parmesan Sauce
$0.50
Cajun Sauce
$0.50
Phooey Farm's Peach Salsa
$0.50
Ancho Honey Buerre Blanc
$0.50
Key Lime Buerre Blanc
$0.50
Mango Salsa
$0.50
1619 W 5th Street Ashtabula, Ohio 44004
440-964-3222
*Prices are subject to change*
Fried by the Pound
Lake Erie Perch
$24.99/#
Jumbo Shrimp
$17.99/#
Haddock
$19.99/#
Sea Scallops
$32.99/#
Chicken Breast
$9.99/#
Crab Sticks
$7.99/#
Select Oysters
$23.99/#
Ocean Perch
$11.99/#
Clam Strips
$28.99/#
Catfish
$14.99/#
Alaskan Pollock
$7.99/#
Walleye
$19.99/#
Sandwiches
Lake Erie Perch
$11.99
Seafood Salad
$6.99
Haddock
$8.99
Chicken Breast
$6.99
Alaskan Pollock
$5.99
Ocean Perch
$7.99
Select Oysters
$10.99
Catfish
$7.99
Crab Cake
Walleye
Shrimp Basket
$9.99
Seafood Dinners
Dinners are served with a sauce of your choice, French fries, hush puppies and a fountain drink.
Lake Erie Perch
$26.99
Alaskan Pollock
$9.99
Haddock
$20.99
Crab Sticks
$9.99
Sea Scallops
$27.99
Jumbo Shrimp
$19.99
Ocean Perch
$11.99
Select Oysters
$25.99
Clam Strips
$30.99
Catfish
$16.99
Sides
French Fries
$3.99/1/2#
Onion Rings
$5.50/1/2#
Hush Puppies
$4.50/1/2#
Cheese Sticks
$6.99/6
Fried Mushrooms
$4.99/1/2#
Sauces
Tarter Sauce
$1.50/Small
$3.50/Large
Small $1.50 | Large $3.50
Cocktail Sauce
$1.50/Small
$3.50/Large
Small $1.50 | Large $3.50
Salads
Seafood Salad
$11.99
Seaweed Salad
$11.99/#
Potato Salad
$5.99/#
Calamari Salad
$15.99/#
Coleslaw
$5.99/#